CCP 10-26-2010 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

Approved Commissioner Danger questioned the logistics of the daily effect on the size of the pile if a rain should occur. Mr. Murlowski explained they will be prepared with a poly cover, as well as logs to absorb moisture. Commissioner Schiferl questioned if more than one compost hauler or lawn service companies would have access to the site. Mr. Murkowski stated they would likely not restrict to one hauler. Commissioner Alvey questioned if any projections on maximum amount or average amount of yard waste may be at various times of the year have been made, as well as an analysis of the mix of the yard waste. Mr. Murlowski responded an estimnate of the amount may be 2 or 3 one hundred cubic yards trucks daily. Carl Bakke representing Elk River Compost stated he would expect not to have more than one load on the site at any given time, and has access to other haulers if needed to expedite the removal from the site. Ms. Gundlach reported staff would work through the logistics of the maximum size of piles remaining on the site, and that is something that staff would like to address at the October Planning Commission meeting. Commissioner Zisla inquired if the noise study was done at Long Lake Park. Mr. Murlowski responded that because there were no complaints received from Long Lake Park, the noise study was not done there. Commissioner Zisla noted the park is an asset to New Brighton, and it is important to address any negative impact. Commissioner Danger questioned if Applewood Point is affected. City Planner Gundlach reported there is quite a distance, and no complaints have been received from Applewood Point. Commissioner Zisla suggested addressing issues, even if not complaint driven. Commissioner Zisla asked when the crushing procedure began. Mr. Murlowski responded it began in the spring of 1992. Roger Schilling, 1187 Mississippi St. reported the tailgate noise is loud, as well as the audible beeping that occurs when the trucks reverse. Mr. Schilling expressed concern with the effect of the berm and the evergreens, and requested a noise study be done on Mississippi St as well. Gene Holter a resident on Mississippi St questioned the effect of the run off into Rice Creek, as there are currently issues with Rice Creek filling with dirt and salt. A resident on Rockstone Lane questioned the times of operation, and requested it be reasonable. Sandra Holser, 1283 Mississippi St. expressed concern with the noise in the park setting. Tim Collins, representing Wenk Associates explained the procedures for the noise study. The noise study was done in the areas that thought to be the most vulnerable. The back up alarms were addressed, the alarm is an OSHA requirement, and were included in the overall study. Commissioner Danger questioned the frequency of the noise being measured. Mr Collins explained the ears do not hear low frequencies as well as a high frequency sound. Mr. Collins reported that Minnesota Noise rules limits operational hours to 7:00 am -10:00 pm. The applicant reported their operational hours are typically 7:00 am -1:00 pm. Mr. Schilling questioned if the trucks are meeting the minimum OSHA requirement. City Planner Gundlach reported that the row of Evergreen trees should address the line of site concerns. Commissioner Danger expressed concern with the time it may take for the trees to grow enough to impede the line of site. Commissioner Schiferl questioned the width of the berm, and suggested a double row of evergreens. Mr. McPherson questioned the L50 rating. Mr. Collins reported it is slightly above the the average, and the proposed reduction of 56.5 would meet the state requirements. Mr. Murlowski reported all trucks back up to dump. Commissioner Danger questioned if the trucks could avoid backing up, Mr. Murlowski responded all could with the exception of the end dump trucks. Commissioner Zisla questioned how many trucks would access the site daily. Mr. Murlowski responded at real busy times anywhere form 100-150, average of 50 a day. Chair Howard suggested highlighting the concerns that were discussed. Ms Gundlach reported the following concerns • The 40 x 40 concrete bunker requires a plan including a cover at night. • Be sure the haulers are running under the MPCA rules.