CCP 02-11-2014 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

Approved Task Force. He stated one very bad idea was to have to get formal permission and if an activity was legal it should be legal for everyone. Claire Stephens, 720 Forest Dale Road, stated she has spent her life growing up with chickens and fresh produce and outdoor activities she could take part in. She stated she struggled with mental illness and she found the raising of chickens and fresh produce a positive in her life. She stated if these rights were taken away it made her sad for all of the children who would not understand a sense of community and the outdoors. Delany Norman, stated they should have chickens because they teach people about agriculture and they are fun to be around. She stated they teach you a lot about agriculture and they are really good and you just love them a lot. She stated you should have chidden because they teach you so much and she knew a lot more about chickens because they have them now. Recently one of her roosters died and they were very sad so they should have chickens because they love them a lot. David Knight, 2153 Violet Lane, stated he has called New Brighton home for 41 years of his 44 years. He stated he moved back three years ago and one of the first things he did was put in a raised bed garden and is fortunate to live near another resident who has chickens. He stated he enjoyed hearing the rooster crow in the morning and he asked them not to create any more rules, but go with the existing rules. Rick Moses, 2049 29th Avenue NW, stated 75 to 100 years ago this was a very rural farming area, but starting about 50 years ago it became a bedroom community with light industry and he liked it that way. He stated it was a residential community an allowing chicken farming would affect residential property values. He stated don't take that out of the equation because it does affect property values. He stated he had a daughter in Shakopee that raises chickens and a set of chickens can really tear up a lawn and roosters were a source of noise pollution so she had to get rid of hers. He noted his daughter had 2 acres, but small acreage such as what New Brighton had did not allow appropriate chicken raising. He recommended a limit on the number of chickens and a limit on acreage. He asked them to take into consideration the number of people who wanted a quiet residential community without urban farming. He stated he had never heard anyone object to raising vegetables. Sharon Ziniel, 715 4th Avenue NW, stated she was an advocate for chicken farming. She stated she had six chickens and most of her neighbors did not even know they had them. She stated they did get rid of their rooster right away. She indicated being a compassionate neighbor, they had called to see what the ordinance was as they didn't want to have any issues, so the rooster was given away. She stated this was a growing experience for everybody coming into a community. She stated she also had a small garden. She believed this was an opportunity to give back to children and everyone involved. She stated they lived in a little 1/4 acre lot and her chickens were penned up, except when they were in the yard. She stated her chickens were no nosier than a dog down the street that barked all day. She believed neighbors would work out their issues in a reasonable, compassionate way. Morris Wolf, 2670 14th ST NW, asked the committee to keep in mind that ordinances were actively enforced by the City and not left to enforcement on a complaint basis. He stated the City has an ordinance against keeping large animals, but a resident is allowed to keep a goat because none of the neighbors complained, but if he wanted to keep a goat and one other neighbors complained, then he could not have one. All residents should be treated equally under the law and the City should not create ordinances that it does not actively enforce on its own. He stated what is not proper for the City to regulate things in the realm of personal aesthetics such as how trees should be trimmed, but public factor things should be regulated. He stated it appeared the City already had ordinances regarding to many issues. He stated the committee needs to be cautious about the noise ordinance and getting too specific created ambiguity and loopholes. He stated if they limited the number of chickens, they needed to focus on the real areas of concerns. He stated the committee needed to look at the broad factors, and avoid getting involved in details and aesthetics. Ken MacCaskie, 3331 Pierce NE, stated he was neither for nor against urban farming, but when they came to the point of ordinances and laws; the more ordinances and laws that were not enforced the more trouble you had and it became a matter of choice. A number of years ago, he came down with end stage renal failure and through the aid of some of the urban gardeners, they raised some money which allowed him to stay in his home. He stated the caring community he was